Gunite vs. Fiberglass Pools: Why Gunite is the Superior Choice

Gunite vs. Fiberglass Pools: Why Gunite is the Superior Choice

When it comes to installing a swimming pool, homeowners often face a crucial decision: gunite vs. fiberglass pools. Both options have their pros and cons, but if you’re looking for the best in customization, durability, and long-term value, gunite swimming pools come out on top. 

In this in-depth guide, we’ll compare the two pool types, highlight the advantages of gunite pools, and discuss the factors that impact gunite pools cost. By the end, you'll understand why a gunite pool is the best investment for your home, and why gunite pools are the best and chosen choice for our expert Volusia and Flagler County pool builders.

What is a Gunite Pool?

A gunite swimming pool is a concrete pool that is built on-site. It starts with a rebar framework, which is then sprayed with a mixture of cement, sand, and water to form a durable shell. Once cured, the surface can be finished with plaster, tile, or pebble finishes, offering endless design possibilities.

Key Features of Gunite Pools:

• Fully customizable in shape, size, and design
• Extremely durable and long-lasting
• Can be finished with various materials for a luxurious look
• Ideal for complex backyard designs, including spas, waterfalls, and tanning ledges

What is a Fiberglass Pool?

A fiberglass pool is a prefabricated shell made from fiberglass-reinforced plastic. These pools are manufactured in a factory and transported to your property, where they are placed into an excavated hole.

Key Features of Fiberglass Pools:

• Pre-molded shapes limit customization
• Smooth gel coat surface
• Faster installation compared to gunite pools
• Less maintenance but limited in terms of repairs and longevity

Now, let’s dive into why gunite pools are the superior choice.

1. Customization and Design Flexibility

One of the biggest advantages of gunite swimming pools is their limitless customization options. Homeowners can design their pool to fit any shape, depth, or feature they desire.

Gunite Pool Customization Options:

• Freeform or geometric shapes
• Custom-built tanning ledges, waterfalls, and spas
• Integrated seating, swim-up bars, and vanishing edges
• A wide variety of finish options, including pebble, tile, and quartz

Fiberglass Limitation: Fiberglass pools are limited to factory-made molds, restricting your ability to customize the design. If your yard has unique dimensions or you want a truly one-of-a-kind pool, gunite is the clear winner.

2. Durability and Longevity

Gunite pools are known for their superior durability. The concrete construction ensures they last for decades, making them a great long-term investment.

Why Gunite Pools Last Longer:

• Concrete is stronger than fiberglass and resists wear and tear
• Gunite pools can withstand extreme weather conditions
• Unlike fiberglass, gunite pools don’t suffer from warping or cracking due to soil movement

Fiberglass Weakness: Fiberglass pools have a limited lifespan. Over time, the gel coat finish can fade, crack, or develop blisters, requiring costly repairs.

3. Better Aesthetic Appeal

If you're looking for a high-end, luxurious pool, gunite is the best choice. With countless finish options, gunite pools can match any aesthetic, from tropical oasis to modern elegance.

Gunite Pool Finishes:

• Plaster – Classic and smooth
• PebbleTec – Adds texture and a natural look
• Tile & Mosaic – Perfect for a sophisticated, high-end finish

Fiberglass Limitation: Fiberglass pools have a limited range of colors and textures. Most have a glossy gel coat that may look artificial and can fade over time.

4. Increased Home Value

A well-designed gunite swimming pool significantly boosts home value. The ability to customize and create a resort-like atmosphere makes gunite pools more attractive to potential buyers.

Why Gunite Pools Increase Property Value:

• Custom pools make properties stand out in real estate listings
• High-end materials and features appeal to luxury buyers
• A durable, long-lasting pool reassures homebuyers of its value

Fiberglass Weakness: Many buyers see fiberglass pools as lower-end due to their pre-fabricated nature. They may not add as much value to a home compared to a gunite pool.

5. Gunite Pools Allow for Additional Features

Since gunite pools are built from scratch, you can integrate additional features that enhance functionality and aesthetics.

Popular Features in Gunite Pools:

• Infinity edges – Perfect for luxury homes with scenic views
• Built-in spas – Combine relaxation with your pool
• Beach entries – Create a natural, resort-like entrance
• LED lighting and fire features – Enhance nighttime ambiance

Fiberglass Limitation: Fiberglass pools have limited options for add-ons, and integrating features like tanning ledges or waterfalls may not be possible with certain models.

6. Gunite Pools Cost vs. Fiberglass Pools Cost

The gunite pools cost varies depending on size, design complexity, and additional features. While gunite pools tend to have a higher upfront cost, their durability and added value make them a better long-term investment.

Gunite Pool Cost Breakdown:

• Installation Cost: $50,000 - $100,000+ (depending on size and features)
• Customization Costs: Additional expenses for high-end finishes, spas, waterfalls, and automation
• Maintenance Costs: Requires resurfacing every 10-15 years, but lower risk of major repairs

Fiberglass Pool Cost Breakdown:

• Installation Cost: $40,000 - $80,000 (limited customization options)
• Repair Costs: If the gel coat is damaged, repairs can be expensive
• Lifespan Limitations: May need replacement sooner than a gunite pool

While a fiberglass pool may seem like a more affordable option at first, the longevity and customization of gunite pools make them the smarter investment.

Conclusion: Gunite is the Clear Winner

When comparing gunite vs. fiberglass pools, the advantages of gunite swimming pools are undeniable:

✅ Fully customizable to fit any space and design preference
✅ Stronger and more durable, lasting for decades
✅ Luxurious aesthetics with a variety of high-end finishes
✅ Adds more value to your property
✅ Supports additional features like spas, waterfalls, and infinity edges

While fiberglass pools may be quicker to install, their limited design options, shorter lifespan, and potential for damage make them a less attractive choice in the long run.

If you’re considering a gunite pool for your home, now is the perfect time to start planning your dream backyard. At Affordable Pools, we are your trusted gunite pool builder serving Volusia and Flagler Counties.

Get a free at-home estimate and 3D design mockup from Affordable Pools today.

‍